The Insurance Policy Nobody Plans For

Florida home insurance and real estate transaction

Transaction Leadership · Risk Awareness · Florida Insurance

The Insurance Policy Nobody Plans For

Transaction Leadership · Risk Awareness · Florida Insurance

I recently closed a duplex purchase in St. Petersburg. The property had flooded in the 2024 hurricanes, was still in original condition, and had sat on the market for two years. The buyer was a first-time investor from out of state with no idea how insurance works in Florida, and the deal was written with no inspection at all.

He also didn't want to own the building a single day without insurance. That's where it got complicated.

Most Florida insurers require a 4-point inspection on older homes — typically 30 years and up — before they'll write a standard policy. It covers the roof, electrical, plumbing, and HVAC. In this case, a 4-point wasn't an option. The contract had no inspection period, the property had flood damage, and the utilities had been off for two years. No 4-point meant no standard homeowners policy.

The answer was a builder's risk policy, which covers a property while it's being repaired or renovated. Simple enough, except it wasn't. The buyer tried to sort it out himself first, including with insurance agents back in his home state, and every one of them wanted a 4-point inspection. I told him he needed a different option and took over. Even locally, one agent kept insisting on a 4-point. I explained that it couldn't be done — not practically and not under the contract — and asked what other options the buyer had. Round and round we went. I went to three different companies before I found an agent who understood the situation, then handed the buyer off to her so she could walk him through the policy. He closed with coverage in place from day one.

Who this may affect

  • Homes with flood or storm damage that hasn't been fully repaired
  • Homes bought as-is or with no inspection period
  • Inherited or vacant homes that have been sitting empty for a long time
  • Older homes with original roofs, plumbing, or electrical
  • Out-of-state buyers who can't easily be on site

Not every home on this list will have trouble getting insured, but if yours fits one of these, check your insurance options before you sign — not after.

What to do

If you're buying: Start the insurance conversation the day you go under contract, not the week before closing. Find out early whether the property can pass a 4-point inspection, and what your options are if it can't.

If you're selling: Have your records ready — repair invoices, roof age, permits, and any past inspection reports. If the utilities are off, think about whether getting them back on before listing would open up more buyers.

Either way: Work with an experienced Florida-based independent insurance agent who can shop several companies, listens to the details, and treats your business like it matters. If you're buying here from out of state, don't rely on your agent back home. Florida's insurance market works differently, and an agent who doesn't know it will cost you time you may not have.

That's the part of this job most people never see, and it's often the difference between a deal that closes and one that falls apart.

Buying or selling a property that's been through a storm, sat empty, or needs work? Call me before you sign anything. I'll help you spot the problems early and find the right people to solve them.

(727) 460-6211 · Let's talk →

More insights like this, in your inbox.

Ready to talk?

No pressure, no obligation. Just an honest conversation.

Let's Talk